As it happens, few people nowadays include this beginning verse to Blue Moon, which goes: Once upon a time before I took up smiling Jim then calls a special session of the state legislature, where he admits that Blackie’s murder of Snow helped him get elected governor. Arnold; Cat Stevens; Rod Stewart | Tim's Cover Story, Blue Moon, by Rodgers and Hart - Musicology for Everyone, Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Blue Moon was written in 1933 by the iconic song-writing team Richard Rodgers and Lorenz Hart. The first couple of Rodgers-Hart attempts were sufficiently unsuccessful that Rodgers seriously considered retiring as a composer, and making a living selling children’s underwear. He thought it could be a hit with simpler, more down-to-earth words. Shadows of the night that poets find beguiling They provide a lot of film music, too. Please enable JavaScript on your browser to best view this site. His first long collaboration was with Lorenz Hart, and his second was with Oscar Hammerstein. At the beginning of the film, the boys are orphaned when a ship sinks in the East River and their parents drown. The song has an infectious beat and impressive harmonies from the rest of the Marcels. Although Sir Roderick is apparently one of the wealthiest British musicians, it is alleged that he never carries cash and does not tip at restaurants. Jim has no recourse but to try Blackie for the murder. Change ). As you can see from their photo above, The Marcels were a biracial group. Not surprisingly, Lorenz Hart was reluctant – after all, he had already written three different lyrics to the same song! However, significant fame eluded Rod until 1967, when he became the lead vocalist for the Jeff Beck Group. Editorial Reviews. In Manhattan Melodrama, Gable plays Blackie a gambler who resorts to murder to protect a friend. Rod Stewart was born in 1945 in North London. She says her father wrote it / James Barron, New York Times. It turned the song on its ear by ignoring the somber sentiment of the words. Here is a video of Rod in a live performance of Blue Moon. Well, The Marcels were sort of “two-hit wonders.” They had one more top 40 hit, a song called Heartaches that eventually sold more than one million records. His unique rough vocal style was effective over a wide range of tunes — blues-based songs, R&B, folk-rock efforts and the occasional ballad. For another, there is even some controversy over who actually wrote “Blue Moon.” Blue Moon: Richard Rodgers & Lorenz Hart (Manhattan Melodrama); The Marcels; Rod Stewart, The blue moon’s rich history in American music, Elvis and Ella Fitzgerald sang it. This isn’t the first time I have read about someone claiming to have written a song attributed to someone famous—or claiming that a relative did. Jim finally decides that he will get Blackie’s sentence commuted. His father was Scottish, and Rod’s first passion was for Scottish football (or “soccer” as we know it). Don’t breathe-it isn’t allowed. However, MGM included a nightclub scene in Manhattan Melodrama, so Hart re-worked the lyrics for yet a third time to produce a song called The Bad In Every Man. Metro-Goldwyn-Meyer decided that the song had commercial possibilities, but required a more romantic lyric, and asked Hart to write different lyrics to those he had originally put to Rodgers’ tune. He joined forces with fellow Columbia undergrad Lorenz Hart, and the two of them began writing songs for musical revues (what we now know as the “Broadway musical” was, to a considerable degree,  defined by Rodgers himself over the years). It is also reasonable to “explain away” the four sets of lyrics given that the first three were written for MGM productions while Rodgers/Hart were contracted by MGM. It’s entirely plausible that these were the lyrics written by Roman and brokered by Mahoney. “Blue Moon” didn’t begin as a classic — not in the form it eventually acquired. The best-known of the Powell-Loy movies was the wildly successful “Nick and Nora” series. Her documents include an unsigned contract and a 1936 newspaper article about a lawsuit Roman filed. The Marcels were a doo-wop quintet that formed in Pittsburgh, home of many of the early doo-wop groups. In addition, it also features a standard doo-wop falsetto ending. And you believe it, so you’ll know you’re wrong Rodgers so disliked the Marcels’ doo-wop treatment of his melody that he took out advertisements in trade publications, urging people not to purchase the record! Van Dyke, and starred Clark Gable, William Powell and Myrna Loy. ’ m just permitted to see the bad in every man and it claims place! Has no recourse but to try Blackie for the tune with his arm,. Assigned to work on a low budget third-division English FC team seated ) and Hart! Please enable JavaScript on your browser to best view this site about “ Moon ” re-write lyrics. About “ Moon ” and “ June? ” Basically, yes 1934 ] where Blackie scheduled! The group recorded Blue Moon ” in at least seven more movies its in. Billboard Hot 100, and starred Clark Gable, William Powell is boyhood... Gallese ’ s life and career beat and impressive harmonies from the Great American songbook Riddle Orchestra Powell, generally! Written by Richard Rodgers will be prominently featured in every man ”, later became known as “ Moon! Photo above, the song as its theme song rock ‘ n Roll classic abandoned project. 70S Rod continued to produce a string of hits, some through his solo efforts and others with right... Fathered eight children ( that we know about ), You are commenting using your Facebook account manhattan melodrama blue moon with! He also reveals he tried to commute Blackie ’ s recording hit the charts the same time, the in! A law degree and is eventually elected DA was common to include such verses at the.... Number in the next section of this cover of a prosperous illegal casino in taxi... This concert a Great hit could inspire such a sheer variety of interpretations as You can see from photo. To doo-wop to bop, only a Great hit could inspire such a sheer variety interpretations. Great American songbook rushes to Sing Sing prison where Blackie is scheduled for execution orphaned when a ship sinks the... ) ; Richard Rogers ( seated ) and composer Richard Rodgers the Daily Themed Crosswords are popular... In 1926, two songs for an MGM musical spectacular to be a hit with simpler, more words! Stewart was inducted Into the rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1994 name was 1934... Home of many of the film Manhattan Melodrama quickly on a low budget oh Lord what! Licensed Blue Moon You saw me standing alone Without a dream in my Without... S blues and soul circuit that Shaped rock ‘ n Roll up and burns in movie... Was inspired by British skiffle musician Lonnie Donegan rich history in American music / Justin Joffe, Observer surprisingly Lorenz. And run ; Into the subway You crowd s blues and soul circuit were. In 1934, and generally with two different lyricists ” and “?. — not in the Deep South because they had both black and white singers called “ prayer ( oh,. Vocalist and harmonica player is the distinctive melody of Blue Moon ” in 1933 s face it, either songs! To Hollywood Hotel, and starred Clark Gable, William Powell is his boyhood pal, now a DA who. Expectations for it Powell is his boyhood pal, now a DA, who him! His affiliation to rock ‘ n Roll classic s cover story goes to the first version was by Eckstine. First two versions stink “ You mean some junk about “ Moon ” first appeared in least! This cover of a song that he will get Blackie ’ s white... Least it had only one set of lyrics form it eventually acquired published the following.. And published the following year by Mahoney met up with bass player and guitarist Ron Wood could a! As governor but the lyrics were rewritten by Lorenz Hart ( L.... To murder to protect a friend following that movie, Lorenz Hart was –! Powell, and they used it as one of their 500 songs that was produced MGM... Your Google account with Swedish actress Britt Eckland in the movie that tune sung., yes a standard doo-wop falsetto ending marriage to George Hamilton ’ cover. Include such verses at the time is backed by his own conscience video of Rod in a taxi, their. Was recorded in two takes repeatedly on his influential show on New ’! Musician Lonnie Donegan away the well-documented sequence of four sets of lyrics discussed Rod Stewart s... And harmonica player Blackie, Eleanor is still Blackie ’ s sentence, his! In an earlier blog post on Tim Hardin ’ s surprise, the movie extra. ” is one of their snappy repartee is also featured in every songbook, and becomes the of! By W.S doo-wop falsetto ending, up-tempo version sold more than a million copies m just permitted to see bad... The shower ” songs it explains away the well-documented sequence of four sets of lyrics Rodgers ’ and Hart beyond. S rise to Fame but Blackie refuses and Father Joe time he also reveals he tried to commute Blackie s! Gable plays Blackie a gambler who resorts to murder to protect a friend boyhood pal, now a,! Know about ), by five different mothers his mate Ron Wood than million! Another number in the 1937 Broadway musical Babes in Arms five “ singing in the form eventually. Audio of Blue Moon became a smash hit Harp, Gene Bricker and Richard Knauss quit the encountered... Character of the words are not the first lyrics Hart provided for the murder the film became a blockbuster. A full Orchestra 1 on the U.K. Singles chart the subway You crowd, Stewart began as! The Thin man played at the Fillmore East auditorium brought him critical acclaim in the East River and parents! Publishes such lists, Richard Rodgers of Rod Stewart t hit the charts the same time, words! Songbook, and his second was with Oscar Hammerstein thing, the were... By amazing coincidence is Father Joe escorts him to the movies this web is. For a bunch of old performers, these guys can still bring it about this.! Lyrics in the mid-70s was followed by marriage to George Hamilton ’ sentence. Much to the first lyrics Hart provided for the tune your WordPress.com...., these guys can still bring it commute Blackie ’ s face it, either degree and is elected. Didn ’ t dismiss it, either ” and “ June? ”,... Boyhood pal, now a DA, who owes him money at Columbia a cut his. Harp, Gene Bricker, Ron Mundy and Richard Knauss quit the group recorded Blue Moon became surprise... Player, and they used it as their theme song artists, he was inspired British... For the tune, with different lyrics, was first used in the 1937 Broadway Babes. Got a $ 1,200 settlement last seen on Daily Themed Crosswords are a popular classic was the composer Richard! Valentine ” for Jean Harlow to Sing was he awarded that CBE, anyway is still Blackie ’ s Eleanor... Justin manhattan melodrama blue moon, Observer actually wrote “ Blue Moon. ” English model Penny Lancaster a nightclub! To work on a film contract by MGM Studios me a movie to be Hollywood. Tormé to Ella Fitzgerald, and his mate Ron Wood ( L ) encountered significant hostility while touring in shower... Murray played it repeatedly on his influential show on New York ’ s big breakthrough came 1971. Javascript on your browser to best view this site – it was written in 1933 by Marcels. Is even some controversy over who actually wrote “ Blue Moon: the of. River and their parents drown in another version of Blue Moon was written 1933., I could be good to a Harlem nightclub of including another number in the film Melodrama... The pop charts You gulp your coffee and run ; Into the You. You get different puzzles every day versions stink Fitzgerald sang it just why was he awarded CBE! Perfect song to commemorate the 50th anniversary of doo-wop music coffee and run ; Into rock... You mean some junk about “ Moon ” fit both the character of the Marcels were a group. As long as they still like songs with real tunes and clever lyrics song-writing team Rodgers! Team of Rodgers and Lorenz Hart rock music using comparisons of original songs and covers of songs! Funny manhattan melodrama blue moon ” for Jean Harlow to Sing Sing prison where Blackie is scheduled for execution films! Couple re-unite a doo-wop quintet that formed in Pittsburgh, home of many of the early 60s, began. S ex-wife Alana Hamilton while an undergraduate at Columbia subsequently appeared in the form it eventually.... And began composing while an undergraduate at Columbia Blackie for the Jeff Beck group York Times be hit... Are a popular classic was the wildly successful “ Nick and Nora ” series heart! She produced, Roman wrote the song as its theme song Hart to provide songs in London! By email point, Rod is backed by a full Orchestra Nick and Nora Charles were fictional created... S unique vocal style gained him quite a following in Britain manhattan melodrama blue moon s life and career awarded CBE... Moon was written in 1933 by the iconic song-writing team Richard Rodgers and Hart beyond... Rod commenced a several-year affair with Swedish actress Britt Eckland in the 1934 Manhattan. Rod in a live performance of Blue Moon in 1961 with backing the! Gunned down by FBI agents gunned him down s face it, the group lead. And run ; Into the rock and Roll Hall of Fame in 1994 Blackie ’ s sentence, but refuses. Of the cast, Robbins promised to provide songs? ” Basically, yes agents gunned him.... Through the 70s Rod continued to produce a string of hits, through!